Michael's Movie Grade: B-
Review: A good movie and one that fixes some of the problems with previous Cars films, but still a movie with problems of its own.
One of the reasons the Cars movies have not been my favorite Pixar movies is that the characters never felt real to me in the same way that the characters of Toy Story, The Incredibles, Inside Out or Up felt. They felt like rather clichéd movie stereotypes instead of real characters. I never hated these characters, they just didn't grab me like other Pixar characters did. Here for the first time though Lighting McQueen feels real and relatable to me. Like Woody did in Toy Story 2, Lighting is essentially dealing with his own mortality here and his realization that nothing can last forever. While this is mostly due to getting older, any one who has gone through any change in their life can relate. Adding to this is the new character, Cruz who is also a really relatable and fun character, who again goes through an arc that feels real. Unfortunately all the other characters don't feel real here. They are simply again clichéd movie stereotypes.
The best thing about this movie though is a few scenes where the characters talk about Doc Hudson. As many of you may know in the previous movies Doc was voiced by Paul Newman, who has passed away recently. While it is never actually stated that the character has died as well it is easy to know that is what happened. These scenes are treated with the upmost dignity and respect. These scenes are just beautifully touching tributes to Paul Newman, and are easily the most moving scenes in the series.
Probably the worst problem with this movie is pretty obvious foreshadowing. All this foreshadowing kind of makes it hard for you to not know how the movie will end. This wouldn't be as big of a problem though, if the characters weren't so oblivious to it. While it makes sense for these characters to act this way (after all, they don't know they are in a movie), it can get annoying for the audience. You just kind of want them to wake up and realize what is so obvious to you, nd it makes the movie feel longer and each time they don't realize it kind of annoying. Also hurting this movie is the humor, it completely falls flat. Not a single joke actually works and I don't think I really ever laughed watching this.
Despite this the movie has good character development and some quite touching scenes and this makes it well worth watching.
But don't go away I have a short to review. LouMichael's Movie Grade: A
Review: If the feature was too predictable, this short film was anything but. I personally try avoid anything talking about the shorts before Pixar movies, because I like seeing a film without knowing what it is going to be about and it is impossible to do this with a Pixar feature. So everything that happened came as a complete surprise to me and it was well worth it. Likewise I am going to not give much away here and do a really short review so you can have the same experience. This film was fun, clever and all together very charming. It is told in pantomime and dialogue is never missed because this pantomime does nothing but add to the charm of this film. Honestly if you don't want to see Cars 3 and are certain you will not like that movie, I still will tell you should go, this short is easily worth the price of admission.
-Michael J. Ruhland
No comments:
Post a Comment